Lime Sugar Cookies

Is it ridiculous that I bought a recipe book solely for a basil salad dressing?

Does it make it better if I explain that the salad dressing goes on one of my all-time favourite salads from a vegetarian/vegan restaurant in Victoria that I must visit each time I’m back in that city? (Especially interesting considering my carnivore ways.)

Nevermind, it was because of the cookbook that I was led to this fabulous cookie. The sweetness of sugar and tang of lime in neat cookie form. I love all things citrus and these certainly satisfy the craving.


Oddly, I never went to Rebar while I lived in Victoria, which I now realize is a huge shame. Still, I get back to the capital city twice a year, so I can keep my cravings for their salad relatively in check. (Hmmm. Perhaps I should blog about the salad dressing….)

Anyway, when I found their recipe book in a store one day, I bought it immediately. When I got home (as I tried to justify the unnecessary purchase of *yet another* cookbook), I started to flip through and inevitably found a bunch of recipes I wanted to try, including the one for the Lime Sugar Cookies.

Sure, it calls for pepitas (pumpkin seeds) and, sure, there was no way I was going to have those on hand and there was no way I was going to buy them. (Surely, the whole point of cookies is that, in general, there is nothing healthy in the mix?) So, I forewent that step and moved ahead.

Then, on the second time making them, I made a very happy mistake. I doubled the recipe, but then didn’t fully double the amount of flour. As a result, the cookies came out a bit denser and with a nice chew, as opposed to the somewhat cake-y versions previously. I now purposely make that mistake. (And, yes, I still don’t bother with the pepitas.)

The one thing to really be aware of with these cookies is that they probably won’t look fully baked, even if they’re ready to be pulled out of the oven. They’ll look puffed, but still very pale with only a hint of golden at the edges. Once you pull them out and they start to cool, they’ll fall slightly and get the nice sort of cracked top to them.

It was raining today when I made these before going in to work. The grey skies made me a bit homesick for Vancouver. But this light and tangy cookies were cheerful, a little taste of summer.







Here is the recipe as printed in the Rebar Modern Food Cookbook. My notes and changes are in italics.

Lime Sugar Cookies

  • 1 cup granulated sugar
  • 1/4 cup unsalted butter
  • 1 tbsp. vegetable oil
  • zest of 1 lime
  • 1 large egg
  • 2 tbsp. lime juice
  • 1 3/4 cups unbleached flour (I use all purpose)
  • 1/4 cup pepitas (pumpkin seeds), toasted and roughly chopped
  • 1/2 tsp. baking soda
  • 1/2 tsp salt

Preheat the oven to 350F. Cream the sugar, oil, butter and lime zest until light and fluffy. Add egg and lime juice, and beat together to incorporate.

In a separate bowl, mix the flour, pepitas, baking soda and salt. Add the dry mix to the wet mix and stir together well.

Using a 2 oz. ice cream scoop or forming 3 tbsp balls (or, in my case, a big rounded soup spoon), drop the batter onto a cookie sheet, leaving space in between to allow the cookies to spread during baking. Flatten each slightly and sprinkle with granulated sugar. Bake for eight minutes. Cool on a wire rack.

As I said above, I always double this recipe (11 cookies is not enough), but instead of using 3 1/2 cups of flour, I only use 3. Feel free to try it both ways.

You may also like


  1. I love the Rebar cook book!! I live in Victoria but I rarely ever go there to eat (I don’t know why we have always enjoyed our meal)….but the cook book I use often… everything I have tried I have loved…I have considered these cookies but have yet to make them…

  2. These were amazing. So was the batter. Speaking of batter…when I tried my hand at these the batter was very soft. I expected it to be somewhat less than firm given the cooking time but it was a little unnerving. I also discovered that I shouldn’t flatten the tops of them as I was greeted with cookie pancakes when I opened the oven door.
    After adjusting the size of my scoop and leaving the tops as is (they flattened out just fine and still left me with that marvelous crackle top) everything seemed to be going well. Until I checked back to take a look at your pictures that is. I can see that your cookies turned out much thicker than mine which leads me back to the batter.
    There doesn’t seem to be a particularly high butter to flour ratio so they wouldn’t have a TON of spread.
    Perhaps I used too much lime juice. You know I have a weakness for all things citrus and spicy in my cooking.
    Thoughts on what to do to improve?
    In any event, they were still amazing and passed the ultimate cookie test…a room full of two year olds.
    Now post the damn scone recipe.

  3. Made these yesterday with lemon rather than lime and they were delicious. I made the stated quantity (rather than doubling it) but weirdly had to add extra flour – and still got a chewy cookie. Mmmm.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *